Separation of powers in administrative law in India

हिंदी में पढ़ें
June 23, 2019
By Advocate Chikirsha Mohanty



The separation of powers is based on the principle of trias politica, which means separation between three independent powers in nation i.e. Legislature, Administration and Judiciary. The legislature makes laws, the executive enforces them and the judiciary applies them to the specific cases arising out of the breach of law.

Administrative law concerns with powers and procedures of administrative agencies, including judicial review of administrative action. It does not include the enormous mass of substantive law produced by the agencies.

Connect with an expert lawyer for your legal issue
 

Separation of Powers in India

The doctrine of separation of powers has not been accorded a Constitution status. Apart from the directive principles laid down in Article 50 of the constitution which sets out separation of judiciary from the executive functions, the constitutional schemes do not embody any dogmatic division of powers.

In the Indian Constitution, the executive powers are vested with the President, the legislative powers with the Parliament and the judicial powers with the judiciary- the Supreme Court, the High Courts and Subordinate Courts. The President holds his office for a fixed period. His functions and powers are enumerated in the Constitution itself. Parliament of India is competent to make any law, subject to the provisions of the constitution and it can also amend the law prospectively or even retrospectively but it cannot declare a judgment delivered by a competent court void or of no effect.

Consult: Top Civil Lawyers in India

The judiciary is independent in its field and there can be no interference with its judicial functions either by the executive or the legislature. The Supreme Court and High Courts are given the power of judicial review and they can declare any law passed by Parliament or Legislature as ultra vires or unconstitutional.

Taking into account these facts, the judiciary has from time to time upheld the principle of separation of powers and accommodated the flexibilities of its function.

In Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab, it was held “It is the basic postulate under the Indian Constitution that the legal sovereign power has been distributed between the legislature to make law, the executive to implement the law and the judiciary to interpret the law within the limits set down by the Constitution."

The Supreme Court in Ram Jawaya Kapur v. State of Punjab, held that: “Indian Constitution has not indeed recognized the doctrine of separation of powers in its absolute rigidity but the functions of the different parts or branches of the governments have been sufficiently differentiated.”

Connect with an expert lawyer for your legal issue

In Delhi Development Authority v M/s UEE Electricals Engg. Pvt. Ltd, the Supreme Court made the observation that “One can conveniently classify under three heads the grounds on which administrative action is subject to control by judicial review. The first ground is “illegality", the second “irrationality" and the third “procedural impropriety".

In Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain Ray, the Chief Justice, also observed that in the Indian Constitution there is separation of powers in a broad sense only.

Therefore, in conclusion, we see that organs of the state remain separated and this position of separation of powers doctrine has been upheld by the rulings made by the courts. No organs can encroach upon the others ambit of powers, and in case an attempt is made even by way of an amendment it has been struck down to uphold the basic structure doctrine.

Connect with an expert lawyer for your legal issue
 

Applicability of the Doctrine in current times

In current times the Separation of Powers not only includes organs such as the Executive, the legislature and the judiciary but also institutions like the press and academic institutions. The organs of an open society which hold power have thus increased with the media playing a huge role. Thus, in a modern society, implementation of Separation of Powers doctrine in its absolute terms is an extremely difficult task. Since vesting any one organ with too much power may be very dangerous, a system of checks and balances has been developed over the years, which has even been consistent with many rulings of the Supreme Court as has been discussed previously. Hence though the doctrine of separation of powers is a theoretical concept and may be very difficult to follow completely a compromised version of it is used in our country.



 

These guides are not legal advice, nor a substitute for a lawyer
These articles are provided freely as general guides. While we do our best to make sure these guides are helpful, we do not give any guarantee that they are accurate or appropriate to your situation, or take any responsibility for any loss their use might cause you. Do not rely on information provided here without seeking experienced legal advice first. If in doubt, please always consult a lawyer.


Googling your legal issue online?

The internet is not a lawyer and neither are you.
Talk to a real lawyer about your legal issue.

Popular Civil Lawyers


Advocate Peeyush Kaushik
Dwarka District Court, Delhi
11 years Experience
Advocate R.K. Gupta
Goyal Vihar, Indore
19 years Experience
Advocate Vijay Tangri
Saket, Delhi
20 years Experience
Advocate Surangama Sharma
Gomti Nagar, Lucknow
4 years Experience

Related Articles


Connect with top Civil lawyers for your specific issue

Civil Law Articles


How to file Writ Petition?

All you need to know about Breach of Contract

Here is what you can do to fight Noise Pollution

Indian law relating to Ad Posters

User Reviews


4.7 - 22 reviews

June 23, 2019 Separation of powers in administrative law in India https://lawrato.com/assets/images/lawguide.png
LawRato
A
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

what is doctrine of separation of powers?

Akansha on Jul 06, 2019
A
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

please state about the division of powers

Arun on Aug 03, 2019
S
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

nicely written please state more about executive

Surendra on Aug 09, 2019
P
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

good article on separation of powers

Prakash on Aug 15, 2019
S
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

very well written. Please tell more about the work of exxecuive, legislature and judiciary

Sumit on Jul 12, 2019
K
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

very good article. Good writing

Krishan on Jul 05, 2019
S
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

I want to know more about this law. Good work

Shyam on Aug 05, 2019
V
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

very well written

Vidya on Aug 11, 2019
S
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

learned all the basics about the legal issue. Good article. Keep it up.

Srinivas on Jul 08, 2019
A
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

Very helpful for my legal case.

Ayush on Aug 04, 2019
R
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

The writer has explained the law perfectly.

Raman on Aug 19, 2019
S
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

nice article. Good legal advice

Supriya on Aug 17, 2019
P
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

how to contact a lawyer?

Parveen on Aug 12, 2019
A
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

informative

Arun on Jul 21, 2019
S
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

A well written article.

Sandip on Aug 12, 2019
K
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

thanks for the information

Kunal on Jul 23, 2019
M
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

whom to contact for any legal query?

Megha on Jul 19, 2019
V
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

nice article. Thanks for the information

Vidya on Aug 09, 2019
A
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

great legal advice

Ayush on Jul 31, 2019
K
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

nice one. Please share more info

Kishore on Aug 09, 2019
M
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

good article. Very helpful

Mahendra on Jul 30, 2019
R
LawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRatoLawRato

Good work with the article. Solved all my legal queries. Regards.

Rajkumar on Aug 12, 2019

VIEW ALL