LawRato

what is the contested dismissed meaning in court in India?


04-Jul-2024 (In Criminal Law)
Status of district court case Nature of business shows-dismiss. Status shows-contested-dismiss. Does dat means my lawyer has asked to dismiss the case? what is the meaning of contested dismissed?
Answers (6)

Answer #1
163 votes

The meaning of the case status, "Contested Dismissed" (in hindi, maamla kharij) is that the case was contested i.e., both the parties involved in the case duly presented arguments and evidence, through their lawyers, before the court and the court upon such hearing dismissed the case. This means that the court did not decide in favor of the party who filed the case because of which the case has been closed. Your lawyer duly participated in the proceedings and yet the court dismissed your case on merits.

Please note that dismissal of suit differs from rejection of plaint. The key difference between rejection of plaint (in hindi, vadpatr ki asvikriti) and dismissal of suit (in hindi, mamla kharij) is that the rejection of a plaint happens before the defendant is served with summons on the ground that such plaint is defective (Order VII Rule 11, CPC), while the dismissal of a suit happens after the defendant has been served and the trial has commenced on the grounds like non-prosecution, non-compliance with court orders (Order IX, CPC), lack of jurisdiction, or non-maintainability of the suit. In the case of rejection of a plaint, the plaintiff has the option of filing a fresh plaint, while in the case of dismissal of a suit, the plaintiff may have the option of filing an appeal against the dismissal.

Helpful? LawRato17+ LawRato
Answer #2
984 votes
Nopes! It means both parties duly contested the case and, on the merits, it stands dismissed. No fault on the part of the lawyer. Better prepare for appeal and present your case well. There is every chance for reversal. All the best.
Helpful? LawRato25+ LawRato
Answer #3
769 votes

That depends on certain conditions. You need to check the court file because each case has its own details and history. First of all, check the court file to understand the exact reason for dismissal. Only after reviewing the file can it be confirmed whether your lawyer requested the dismissal or if the court dismissed the case for some other reason, such as lack of evidence, absence of parties, or procedural issues. 
 
 

 

Helpful? LawRato8+ LawRato
Answer #4
933 votes
No lawyer will ask to dismiss the case. The case is dismissed when the process is complete, i.e., the suit is filed and the defendant has appeared, written statement evidence produced by the parties' arguments heard, then the court pronounces its decision, i.e., dismissed or decreed. Never doubt the integrity of a lawyer. 
Helpful? LawRato LawRato
Answer #5
743 votes
No, contested dismissed means the Presiding Officer, after going through the entire record and after hearing the pleading of the parties, pronounced the order. Meaning thereby your counsel has not asked to dismiss the case, rather your advocate pleaded your case.
Helpful? LawRato LawRato
Answer #6
622 votes
Dear questioner,
Obviously not. You should first clarify whether you filed the case or were contesting it—meaning, was the case filed by someone else against you? It cannot be presumed that your lawyer asked for the matter to be dismissed. You should confirm the ground on which it was dismissed.
Let me make it clear: if you were contesting the matter, then a dismissal would be in your favour. However, if you filed the case, then you should ask your lawyer the reason for its dismissal.
 
 
Helpful? LawRato LawRato

Disclaimer: The above query and its response is NOT a legal opinion in any way whatsoever as this is based on the information shared by the person posting the query at lawrato.com and has been responded by one of the Divorce Lawyers at lawrato.com to address the specific facts and details.

Report abuse?

Comments by Users

No Comments! Be the first one to comment.

"lawrato.com has handpicked some of the best Legal Experts in the country to help you get practical Legal Advice & help."