When a defendant dies, can his legal representatives amend his written statement? Or, should they file fresh written statements? Does the limitation begin from the date of their impleadment into the suit? Do they have to file all the documents? In the case of plaintiffs, they keep amending the same plaint when a plaintiff dies, but why do defendants have to file new written statements when a defendant dies?
Dear Client,
Upon the death of a defendant, the legal representatives ordinarily cannot simply substitute their own written statement without following the procedure prescribed by law. Under Order XXII Rule 4 CPC, the legal representatives may be brought on record, subject to limitation and applicable exceptions. They may seek permission under Order XXII Rule 4(2), read with Order VIII CPC, to file an appropriate written statement, particularly where their personal knowledge or independent defence is relevant. A fresh written statement is not automatically mandatory in every case.
Limitation for substitution is generally 90 days from the date of death under Article 120 of the Limitation Act, 1963, subject to applicable provisions and condonation where legally permissible. The period ordinarily runs from death, not from the date of impleadment. Delay and procedural requirements must be examined carefully.
Legal representatives are not required to file every document indiscriminately. They should produce relevant documents relied upon in their defence, complying with the CPC and the court’s directions.
The distinction between plaintiffs and defendants arises because the cause of action and relief claimed may continue through the plaintiff’s legal representatives, whereas a deceased defendant’s representatives may need to establish their own permissible defence. However, the court’s permission and procedural compliance remain essential.
The precise remedy depends upon the stage of proceedings, nature of the defence, and applicable High Court precedents.
Regards,
Adv. Udit Garg
Dear Sir/Madam, under Order XXII Rule 4(2) CPC, the legal representatives of a deceased defendant may raise a defence appropriate to their capacity as legal representatives. They may be permitted to file an additional or separate written statement, but they cannot ordinarily introduce pleas inconsistent with the deceased defendant’s defence or raise pleas that were personal to the deceased. The Supreme Court has recognised this right in Bal Kishan v. Om Parkash and Sumtibai v. Paras Finance Co.
There is no universal rule requiring a fresh written statement in every case. The legal representatives should seek permission from the court and file their defence promptly after being impleaded. The applicable timeline depends on the nature of the suit, the stage of proceedings and the court’s directions; commercial suits may be subject to stricter timelines. They must file the documents on which they rely in accordance with the applicable CPC provisions, rather than necessarily filing every document in their possession.
If a plaintiff dies, the legal representatives ordinarily continue the proceedings on the basis of the existing pleadings, subject to any necessary consequential amendments. Similarly, the death of a defendant does not, by itself, make a fresh written statement compulsory if an existing written statement adequately covers the defence. The object is to ensure a fair opportunity to defend the suit, not to restart the entire pleading process automatically.
Under Order XXII Rule 4(2) CPC, the legal representatives (LRs) of a deceased defendant are not automatically required to file a fresh written statement if the deceased defendant had already filed one. They can ordinarily adopt and rely upon the existing written statement. However, they may seek the Court’s permission to file an additional or amended written statement, subject to the applicable procedural rules and the stage of the proceedings.
If the deceased defendant had not filed a written statement, the LRs may seek permission to file one, but their substitution does not automatically entitle them to a fresh opportunity to file it irrespective of the stage of the suit.
There is no general requirement to refile all documents already forming part of the judicial record. The LRs may rely upon the existing record, while any additional documents must be filed in accordance with the applicable procedural requirements.
The position is not fundamentally different merely because the deceased party was a defendant rather than a plaintiff. The existing plaint ordinarily continues after substitution of the plaintiff’s LRs, just as the existing written statement ordinarily continues after substitution of the defendant’s LRs. Any amendment or additional pleading must be considered in accordance with the CPC and the facts of the particular case.
The precise course of action will depend on whether the deceased defendant had already filed a written statement, the stage of the proceedings, and whether the LRs seek to introduce any new or additional defence.
written statement based on the time line and what they show and present the court for agreement, each and every suit is different from civil prospective and you have to see the time then they can file but if timeline does not allow then it would be rejected,
however to understand the timeline you have show us the documents and court file and we can say a solid answer to you
Himanshu Sharma
Advocate
VIGILANT LEGUM LAW FIRM
Dwarka Delhi
When a defendant dies during the pendency of a civil suit, the legal representatives (LRs) are ordinarily brought on record under Order XXII Rule 4 CPC. They are not automatically required to file a completely fresh written statement. The LRs may adopt the deceased defendant’s existing written statement and, if necessary, seek leave of the court to amend or file an additional written statement, subject to the scope of their defence and the applicable procedural law.
Disclaimer: The above query and its response is NOT a legal opinion in any way
whatsoever as this is based on the information shared by the person posting the
query at lawrato.com and has been responded by one of the Divorce Lawyers at lawrato.com to
address the specific facts and details.