If I file a case u/s 9 of HMA, do I have to give maintenance to wife

555 votes

Yes,if the family court orders so,the courtWill not automatically order for maintenance.if opposite party apply for maintenance,you may oppose on the ground that she is leaving separately without any reasonable reason.

Advocate Girdhar Prasad Upwanshi LawRato

824 votes

Aap k sawal jayaz hai jab patni apni marzi say alag reh rahi hai tab bharan poshan kyu ??

Pehla section 9 abhi pending hai uss may final order nahi hua jiss mey yeh saabit ho Chuka ho k patni apni marzi say alag hai who bhi bina kisi uchit karna k . Jo evidence say saabit hoga (matter of trial) nirnay say porva nahi.

Dusra section 9 pending rehtey bhi ladki maintainance k liye section 125 crpc may bharan poshan k liye aavedan dey sakti hai who alag case hoga jiss par final order section 9 ka prabhav pad sakta hai na ki pending case ka.

Teesra pehluu yeh hai k jab tak court k aagey section 9 HMA ka case pending hai or yeh sabit he nahi hua hai k ladki apni marzi say alag reh rahi hai tab tak tho weh section 9 k pending case may bhi section 24 family court act k tahet paisa paaney ko aavedan laga sakti hai ...

Law har case k tathya or paristhithi (fact and circumstances ) k anusaar laagu hoga.

Detail reply k liye detail query post karey ya kissi vakil say call / mill kar salah ley.

Advocate Varun Kaushik LawRato

860 votes

Section 9 aur bharan poshan dono alag alag cheezein hain. Inka aapas me koi relation nhi hai. Kripya in dono kanoonon ko mix Na karein. Aapko kya relief chahie wo specifically humko bataen tab hum aapki madad kar paenge

Advocate Manav Tanwani LawRato