2 cheque deposited in 2 district on 2 different agreement NI ct
2 cheque deposited in 2 district on 2 different agreement NI ct
07-Oct-2025 (In Cheque Bounce Law)
THi
1. Explain section 142A of NI ACT?
2. Two cheque on 2 different agreement within same drawer and drawee, can drawer file cheque bouncing in same court despite of drawer bank lies in 2 different districts?
3. Is any case law available on mis calculation made and excess amount mentioned in cheque, wrongful interest charged in agreement paper, jurisdiction ground for dismiss of case filed in same court despite of different district of bank?
As per section 142A of NI act, all the pending cases will be transferred to the jurisdiction where the payee has filed a complaint against the drawer of the cheque having jurisdiction under sub- section 2 of section 142. All the subsequent cases will be filed in the same court. For any further relief, Need to check what has been mentioned in the agreement with the party.
Do seek a detailed legal Consultation for your issue. Law is very clear now and the complaint case would be filed before the Honble JMFC in the district where the payee or holder of the cheque maintains the bank account. No cheque bouncing cannot be filed if the payee maintains a Cheque in two different districts
Under Section 142A of the NI Act, cheque bounce cases are filed where the payee’s bank is located. If both cheques (even from different agreements) were presented through the same bank branch, they can be tried in one court. Otherwise, separate jurisdictions apply.
Errors in calculation or excess amount are trial issues, not jurisdictional grounds. Bridgestone India Pvt. Ltd. v. Inderpal Singh (2016) clarifies this rule.
Section 142A ensures that for cheque bounce cases under Section 138, once jurisdiction is fixed (first valid complaint) between same parties and drawer, further complaints must be before the same court, avoiding forum shopping and multiplicity. Even if drawer’s bank branch lies in a different district, what matters per Section 142(2) and then 142A is how the cheque was delivered/presented, and where the first valid complaint is pending. Issues like excessively mentioned amount, wrongful interest, miscalculation are defenses, not jurisdictional grounds (unless the claim is entirely untenable). If case is filed in an improper court (wrong jurisdiction), that is a ground to have the case quashed or transferred.
Section 142A of the Negotiable Instruments (Amendment) Act, 2015 clarifies the question of jurisdiction in cheque dishonour cases filed under Section 138 of the NI Act. Earlier, there was confusion about whether such cases should be filed where the cheque was drawn, presented, or dishonoured. Section 142A now provides that the proper jurisdiction lies with the court within whose local limits the bank branch of the payee or holder in due course, where the cheque was presented for collection, is situated. This means the case must be filed where the payee’s bank branch is located, not where the drawer’s bank is situated.
In a situation where two cheques have been issued under two separate agreements between the same drawer and drawee, but the drawer’s bank branches are in different districts, both cases can still be filed before the same court if the payee deposited both cheques in the same account at the same bank branch. Section 142A(2) specifically allows consolidation of complaints between the same parties before one court where the payee’s bank branch is situated, ensuring convenience and consistency. Therefore, it is legally permissible to file both cheque bounce complaints in the same court despite the drawer’s banks being in different districts.
Disputes such as errors in calculation, excess amounts written on the cheque, or inclusion of wrongful interest clauses in the underlying agreement generally do not affect the validity of a cheque bounce case. Proceedings under Section 138 focus on whether the cheque was issued towards a legally enforceable debt or liability and whether it was dishonoured for insufficient funds or related reasons. The criminal court under the NI Act does not adjudicate on the correctness of the transaction amount or terms of the agreement. However, the accused can raise such issues as a defence during the trial to demonstrate that no legally enforceable liability existed on the date of issuance of the cheque.
If the cheque was issued with an exaggerated amount or interest, it will not invalidate the complaint under Section 138 unless there is clear proof that the cheque was altered or obtained fraudulently. Such matters can be taken separately before a civil court through a counterclaim or independent suit for adjustment of accounts.
The Supreme Court in Bridgestone India Pvt. Ltd. v. Inderpal Singh (2016) 2 SCC 75 has confirmed that the place of jurisdiction for filing a cheque dishonour complaint is the location of the payee’s bank where the cheque was presented for collection. Even if the drawer’s bank is located in a different district, the case filed in the payee’s jurisdiction remains valid and cannot be dismissed on jurisdictional grounds. The amendment under Section 142A has retrospective effect and applies even to cases already pending.
Disclaimer: The above query and its response is NOT a legal opinion in any way
whatsoever as this is based on the information shared by the person posting the
query at lawrato.com and has been responded by one of the Divorce Lawyers at lawrato.com to
address the specific facts and details.