LawRato

Cultivating tenant fake case dismissal


18-Oct-2026 (In Property Law)
Some people worked in a mango garden in the past and filed a completely fake case that they are CULTIVATING TENANTS and they cannot be evicted. They falsely claimed that they worked in the mango garden for generations. Do the normal civil courts have JURISDICTION to deal with issues related to cultivating tenants or should they approach District Collector or other officials? Did any of you come across such a fake case related to cultivating tenants? What kind of reply should be given?
Answers (5)

Answer #1
579 votes
Kindly share a complete copy of the plaint filed by the opposite party, along with any interim applications and the latest order passed by the court. I will examine the pleadings, the grounds on which cultivating tenancy has been claimed, and the relevant revenue records to assess the maintainability of the claim and the appropriate legal remedy. After reviewing the documents, we can determine whether the matter falls within the jurisdiction of the civil court or whether any specific statutory remedy before the competent revenue authority is applicable. The next course of action will depend on the applicable tenancy law, the nature of the land, and the evidence available.
Helpful? LawRato LawRato
Answer #2
619 votes
Dear Sir/Madam, the appropriate forum depends on the State’s agricultural tenancy legislation and the relief sought. A claim of cultivating tenancy over a mango garden does not automatically oust the jurisdiction of the civil court. However, where a special tenancy law reserves questions of tenancy status or eviction to a designated revenue authority, the civil court’s jurisdiction may be barred to that extent. The mere fact that the claimants previously worked in the garden does not, by itself, establish that they are cultivating tenants; their actual role, possession, cultivation, payment or sharing of produce, and the applicable statutory requirements must be examined. In your reply, specifically deny the alleged tenancy if it is false, state the true nature and duration of the claimants’ work, and distinguish employment or labour from lawful agricultural tenancy. Seek strict proof of the alleged tenancy, including any lease, rent receipts, crop-sharing records, revenue entries and other contemporaneous documents. Preserve relevant land records, employment or wage records, witness evidence and proof of possession. If the case is pending before a civil court, your advocate should examine whether a jurisdictional objection or an application for determination of the relevant tenancy issue is appropriate. A complaint to the District Collector or revenue authorities may also be considered where supported by the applicable State law, but it does not automatically replace the defence in the pending suit. Do not assume that the claim is false merely because the claimants have no written lease; some tenancy laws recognise other forms of tenancy. The State in which the mango garden is situated and the exact relief claimed are essential to determine the correct forum and the strongest legal reply.
Helpful? LawRato LawRato
Answer #3
722 votes
A proper opinion can only be given after examining the pleadings and relevant land records. The first step is to determine the legal and factual grounds on which the claimants are asserting the status of cultivating tenants. We would need to examine the nature of the land, the applicable state tenancy law, the basis on which they claim to have entered into possession, the alleged relationship with the landowner, and the documentary evidence supporting their claim of cultivation over generations. Merely working in a mango garden does not, by itself, establish the status of a cultivating tenant or confer protection against eviction. Their actual role, the nature of their possession, cultivation records, tenancy documents, revenue entries and other relevant evidence must be examined. The question of jurisdiction also depends on the applicable state legislation. Certain tenancy laws confer jurisdiction on designated revenue authorities, while the jurisdiction of civil courts depends on the nature of the dispute and any statutory bar. Please share the state and district where the mango garden is situated, along with the relevant pleadings or court order, if available. We can then examine the legal basis of their claim, the appropriate forum, and the grounds on which the claim may be challenged. Regards, Himanshu Sharma VIGILANT LEGUM LAW FIRM
Helpful? LawRato LawRato
Answer #4
918 votes
The jurisdiction of the Civil Court depends upon the applicable State land and tenancy laws, the nature of the land, and the relief claimed. Where the land is agricultural and the alleged occupants claim the status of cultivating tenants, the relevant State tenancy legislation must be examined to determine whether the matter falls within the jurisdiction of the Civil Court, Revenue Court, or a designated authority such as the District Collector or Tenancy Tribunal.
Helpful? LawRato LawRato
Answer #5
646 votes
in this matter you should deny the claim of tenant and clearly refer to root 6 of CPC and ask for the records of their tenancy the bills etc whatever the documents they are claiming that they had been being here for generation to generation also you should be presenting your Khatauni Khasra and every documents and event tax receipt to the government which your family might be paining from generation to generation to the land and the proof of ownership this will solve your problem because this is a very popular form of method of extraortation of money without fail you can do this and the judgement will be near decision in your favor also if you further need kindly contact us we will also help you in providing the returns statement and other document so that you can win the case and have the case in your
Helpful? LawRato LawRato

Disclaimer: The above query and its response is NOT a legal opinion in any way whatsoever as this is based on the information shared by the person posting the query at lawrato.com and has been responded by one of the Divorce Lawyers at lawrato.com to address the specific facts and details.

Report abuse?

Comments by Users

No Comments! Be the first one to comment.

"lawrato.com has handpicked some of the best Legal Experts in the country to help you get practical Legal Advice & help."