Admissibility of Photocopy Documents as Evidence in Court: Key Legal Insights
14-Jun-2024 (In Criminal Law)
A photocopy is only secondary evidence and is admissible in court when the statutory conditions for secondary evidence are satisfied (best-evidence rule as re'stated in the new Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam and the earlier Evidence Act provisions). See BSA / IEA provisions. The Supreme Court has consistently ruled that mere production of a photocopy is not enough: J. Yashoda v. K. Shobha Rani (photocopies cannot be received as secondary evidence if they were not compared with the original). [https://lawfyi.io/smt-j-yashoda-vs-smt-k-shobha-rani-on-19-april-2007/] The Court has also held that a photocopy is insufficient where genuineness is disputed (United India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Anbari). [https://indiankanoon.org/doc/113530318/] At the same time the Court has warned trial courts not to reject secondary evidence mechanically (Nawab Singh v. Inderjit Kaur). [https://ecourtsindia.com/CNR/SCIN010187561998] More recently the Court explained that no separate formal petition is always required to lead secondary evidence but a clear factual foundation must be laid before admitting photocopies (Dhanpat v. Sheo Ram). [https://indiankanoon.org/doc/9381542/] Finally, the Court reiterates that admission/exhibition of a photocopy does not equal proof; the probative value must be tested at trial (Rakesh Mohindra v. Anita Beri). [https://www.legitquest.com/case/rakesh-mohindra-v-anita-beri/95ac2] For the statutory rule on secondary evidence, see the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (which supersedes the old Evidence Act) and the corresponding provisions dealing with proof by primary and secondary documentary evidence. [https://courtbook.in/search/act/the-bharatiya-sakshya-adhiniyam-2023-6690db0827e75d8a5ebb2db5]
22+
- The original document is in the possession of the person against whom it is to be proved, or in the hands of someone outside the court’s jurisdiction, or legally bound to produce it, but fails to do so after being notified under Section 66.
- The original document has been lost, destroyed, or cannot be produced within a reasonable time due to circumstances beyond the offering party’s control.
- The original is immovable or cannot be easily transported.
Key Supreme Court Judgments on Photocopy Evidence:
- J. Yashoda v. K. Shobha Rani (AIR 2007 SC 1721): The Supreme Court ruled that if the original document is not available for comparison, photocopies cannot be accepted as secondary evidence.
- Nawab Singh v. Inderjit Singh Kaur (AIR 1999 SC 1668): In this case, the Supreme Court held that rejecting the tenant’s application to produce a photocopy of a rent note without allowing secondary evidence was unjustified.
- Dhanpat v. Sheo Ram (Civil Appeal No. 1960 of 2020): The court clarified that there is no requirement to file a formal application to produce secondary evidence, and a photocopy could be accepted even if such an application was not filed.
- Aher Rama Gova & Ors. v. State of Gujarat (1979 4 SCC 500): The Supreme Court allowed a photocopy of a lost dying declaration to be presented as secondary evidence because the parties did not dispute its admissibility, and the necessary foundation was laid.
18+
Now, let’s examine if a photocopy can be classified as secondary evidence. For a photocopy to be admissible as secondary evidence, there must be clear testimony indicating that the photocopy was made from the original document or that it was compared to the original. Without such verification, a photocopy cannot be accepted as secondary evidence.
Therefore, a photocopy is only admissible if it is a certified copy. A simple photocopy, without proper certification or proof that it was compared to the original, cannot be relied upon in court. For any document to be deemed admissible, it must meet the requirements for primary or secondary evidence as specified under Sections 64, 65, and 66 of the Evidence Act.
The Supreme Court in J. Yashoda v. K. Shobha Rani (AIR 2007 SC 1721) held that secondary evidence is admissible only when primary evidence is absent and a proper explanation is provided for its unavailability.
12+
7+
14+
Disclaimer: The above query and its response is NOT a legal opinion in any way
whatsoever as this is based on the information shared by the person posting the
query at lawrato.com and has been responded by one of the Divorce Lawyers at lawrato.com to
address the specific facts and details.
No Comments! Be the first one to comment.
"lawrato.com has handpicked some of the best Legal Experts in the country to help you get practical Legal Advice & help."
2+ Lawyers are online
