LawRato

Society Maintenance Charges - Latest Court Judgement


    What are the judgements about

    The judgments detailed in this article pertain to the law laid down by the legislature and expanded by the judiciary on maintenance charges collected by housing societies in India. It is common practice in most modern housing societies to set up a managing body which collects periodic charges from residents for the maintenance and upkeep of the societies and their common utilities. The quantum of these charges often varies depending upon the utilities and amenities being offered by a housing society to its residents and this is often calculated based on different methods.

    What were the issues being decided in the judgements?

    The Supreme Court has decided on numerous issues such as the legality of levying maintenance charges from residents and the rights of societies to collect arrears. The Supreme court has also decided upon the issue of whether maintenance charges fall under the definition of rent. In another judgment, the Supreme Court decided an action arising out of non-payment of repairs and maintenance charges.

    What was held by the court in these judgements?

    In a landmark judgment, the Supreme Court considered the definition of the term ‘rent’ and held that it was comprehensive enough to include the provision of all amenities agreed to be provided to the resident at the cost of the landlord. Further, in another decision, the Supreme Court held that members of a society are liable to pay such dues as determined by a society towards the maintenance and upkeep of flats and common utilities. The Supreme Court also recognised the rights of a society to collect the arrears and costs from members who failed to pay such dues on time.

    Download Complete Judgement

    Judgement

    SUPREME COURT

    Rasila S. Mehta And Others v. Custodian,

    Nariman Bhavan,

    Mumbai


     JUDGEMENT 

    P. Sathasivam, J.— Civil Appeal No. 2924 of 2008 has been filed by Smt Rasila S. Mehta,

    mother of late Harshad S. Mehta and Civil Appeal No. 2915 of 2008 has been filed by Smt

    Rina S. Mehta, sister-in-law of late Harshad S. Mehta against the final judgment and

    order dated 26-2-2008 passed by the Special Court under the provisions of the Special

    Court (Trial of Offences Relating to Transactions in Securities) Act, 1992 (hereinafter

    referred to as “the Act”) at Bombay in Miscellaneous Petitions Nos. 2 and 1 of 2007

    respectively whereby the Special Court dismissed their petitions challenging the

    Notification dated 4-1-2007 issued by the Custodian exercising powers under Section

    3(2) of the Act notifying the appellants.



    2. Civil Appeal No. 3377 of 2009 has been filed by Smt Jyothi H. Mehta, widow of late

    Shri Harshad S. Mehta and six others against the judgment and order dated 13-3-2009

    passed by the Special Court in approving Report No. 19 of 2008 filed by the Custodian in

    respect of outstanding dues towards Flats Nos. 32-A, 32-B, 33, 34-A and 34-B on the third

    floor and 44-A, 44-B and 45 on the fourth floor together with terrace area on the third

    floor and eight car parking spaces in Madhuli Cooperative Housing Society Ltd., Worli

    belonging to late Harshad S. Mehta as well as other related notified entities of the

    Harshad Mehta Group......



    Download complete judgement by clicking on the button given below >>



    Download Complete Judgement

    What law does the judgement discuss?

    The judgments mentioned in this article discuss the legality and law related to the collection of maintenance charges by housing societies in India in relation to property law and rent control legislations in India.

    Why do you need a Lawyer?

    It is imperative to understand the legality and the guidelines which govern the collection and payment of society maintenance charges in India to ensure you are not being duped or wronged by the societies under the garb of maintenance charges. The expertise of a trained legal mind can help you understand the law on this aspect and ensure your rights are not being violated. Therefore, it is quintessential to engage the services of a good civil lawyer to make and present your case before a court of law in case of any disputes regarding the society maintenance charges.

  • Disclaimer: The information contained in the sample document is general legal information and should not be construed as legal advice to be applied to any specific factual situation. Any use of the Site or document format DOES NOT create or constitute a solicitor-client relationship between LawRato or any employee of or other person associated with LawRato and a user of the Site. The information or use of documents on the Site is not a substitute for the advice of a lawyer.

Consult top rated Civil Lawyers in India