Property rights for female legal heirs

788 votes

Section 14 of The Hindu Succession Act gives to a female Hindu an absolute title over the properties which under the traditional Hindu law she held as a limited owner. Section 15 of the Act delineates the heirs of a female Hindu and the order in which they are to succeed to her property if she dies intestate. Section 16 of the Act provides the manner of distribution of a deceased female Hindu among her heirs.

Rule 1 of section 16 provides:

Rule 1.-Among the heirs specified in sub-section (1) of section 15, those in one entry shall be preferred to those in any succeeding entry, and those included in the same entry shall take simultaneously.

Therefore, if A, a Hindu female, dies intestate and after her death she is survived by the son of her husband and her own mother. Now, the son of her husband being an heir of her husband figures in entry (b) of sub-section 1 of section 15 and the mother figures in entry (c). As per Rule 1, those in one entry shall be preferred to those in succeeding entries. Therefore, heirs in entry (b) shall be preferred to those in entry (c). Hence son of A’s husband shall inherit the property of A to the exclusion of A’s mother.



If in the above example, A is survived by only her father and mother and no one else, then A’s property shall devolve upon both of them and both shall inherit equally as both of them figure in entry (c) and according to Rule 1 heirs included in the same entry shall take simultaneously. Therefore if in this example, A was survived by any two or more people figuring in the same entry like her own son and daughter, or if she does not have any children of her own, then the children of her husband being his heirs, or the heirs of her father or heirs of her mother, if by operation of law A’s property is to succeed to heirs mentioned in any single category and where they are more than one, they shall inherit equally.

Rule 2:
Rule 2.-If any son or daughter of the intestate had pre-decease the intestate leaving his or her own children alive at the time of the intestate’s death, the children of such son or daughter shall take between them the share which such son or daughter would have taken if living at the intestate’s death.



Rule 2 is self explanatory. For example if A, a Hindu female dying intestate is survived by a son, a daughter and two daughters from one son who had pre-deceased A, i.e. who had already expired before A’s death, then all of them being heirs mentioned in entry (a) of sub-section (1) of section 15, all of them shall be entitled to A’s property. But what would be the share of each of them? Rule 1 says that heirs mentioned in the same entry succeed simultaneously. All the heirs of A are mentioned in entry (a), so do they succeed simultaneously? The answer is provided by Rule 2. Property of A after her death shall be divided in three parts. A’s son and daughter shall take one part each and the remaining one part shall devolve upon the branch of A’s pre-deceased son, i.e. the son and daughter of A’s pre-deceased son shall together inherit one part which their father would have inherited had he been alive. Among themselves however, both of them shall take equally the one part of A’s property that they have inherited. Hence A’s son shall take 1/3rd share in A’s property, A’s daughter shall also take 1/3rd share while A’s grandson and grand-daughter from her predeceased son shall each take 1/6th share in A’s property.

Advocate Siddhant Sharma LawRato

738 votes

Hi, Your query is unclear. You have stated that your Grandfather died in the year 1967 - Female Legal have no right over that property. You have also said that your grandmother died recently leaving behind some properties of her - This property of your grandmother on her demise will devolve to her sons and daughters equally ( you have not mentioned how many sons and daughters in six legal heirs left behind, nevertheless it will devolve in equal proposition according to section 15 of Hindu Succession Act.) Your ultimate query is answered accordingly - female heirs have equal right over their mother's property.

Advocate GP Vijay LawRato