Medical Negligence in India
July 11, 2023By Advocate Chikirsha Mohanty हिंदी में पढ़ें
Table of Contents
In the judgment given in Bolam V/s. Friern Hospital Management Committee (1957) 2 All ER 118. , McNair, J., while addressing the jury summed up the law as under:-
“The test is the standard of the ordinary skilled man exercising and professing to have that special skill. A man need not possess the highest expert skill at the risk of being found negligent. It is a well-established law that it is sufficient if he exercises the ordinary skill of an ordinary competent man exercising that particular art. I do not think that I quarrel much with any of the submissions in law which have been put before you by counsel. Counsel for the plaintiff put it in this way, that in the case of a medical man, negligence means failure to act in accordance with the standards of reasonably competent medical men at the time. That is a perfectly accurate statement, as long as it is remembered that there may be one or more perfectly proper standards; and if a medical man conforms with one of those proper standards then he is not negligent.”
Connect with an expert lawyer for your legal issue
WHAT MUST BE PROVED IN A CASE OF MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE:
There are three essential elements to proving a claim for medical negligence. They are as follows:
-
Medical negligence (breach of the standard of care)
-
Causation
-
Harm (injury and damages)
REASONABLE STANDARD OF CARE: The "standard of care" is what a reasonably prudent medical care provider within the same field or specialty should do in caring for you under the circumstances. In a majority of cases, the opinion of other medical practitioners as to what their conduct would have been under the same circumstances is taken on record to establish what a reasonably prudent medical practitioner should have done under the circumstances.
DEFINITION OF MEDICAL PRACTITIONER: One does not have to be a doctor to be held guilty of medical negligence. Any healthcare provider, like a nurse or an anesthetist, can also be held liable for medical negligence if they fail to act in a prudent and reasonable manner.
PROVING CAUSATION: For a patient/next of kin of a patient who believes that they have been a victim of medical negligence, it is necessary to prove causation. The victim will have to prove that not only did the harm was a result of the medical negligence, but that it was also a reasonably foreseeable injury that would’ve resulted from the said medical error. Causation, which is of two types (1) actual causation and (2) proximate causation, is usually proven through the testimony of one or more qualified experts.
Consult: Top Medical Negligence Lawyers in India
RES IPSA LOQUITOR is a Latin phrase that translates into “the thing speaks for itself”. This is an exception to proving causation for cases where causation is assumed owing to the fact that the resultant injury would have resulted only from a medical error. Eg. In a case of invasive surgery where the medical practitioner leaves an instrument or any foreign material inside the body of the victim, causation would not have to be proved.
INFORMED CONSENT: An ‘informed consent is a document that patients sign prior to undergoing medical treatment or a surgical procedure. However, the fact that the patient signed an informed consent is not a bar to bringing a claim for medical negligence. In fact, the consent is purportedly to inform the patient of the known and anticipated risks and potentially poor outcomes, from a given treatment plan or procedure. It does not constitute a waiver of the patient's right to not be harmed by errors or negligence by the doctor, nurse, or other medical provider. In other words, the patient has the right to be informed that certain adverse (bad) outcomes are a risk of a given treatment or procedure, even where the doctor and medical staff is reasonably prudent in providing the treatment - that is the purpose of the informed consent. It is not meant to preclude you from recovering for injuries and damages which are caused by the negligence of the physicians or staff, as clearly we expect our healthcare providers to provide us with reasonably prudent care.
PROVING MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE: proving a medical malpractice claim is difficult and requires experience and knowledge about the medical standard of care for the particular field of treatment, the mechanism, and causation of the injury, and an ability to keenly assess whether your injury resulted from negligence or was merely a poor outcome. First, one should consult with a competent and experienced medical malpractice attorney, who has extensive experience in handling not just personal injury claims, but specific knowledge and understanding of the handling of medical negligence claims.
Connect with an expert lawyer for your legal issue
PROCEDURAL REQUIREMENT: In India, medical negligence is covered by the Consumer Protection Act. In certain cases, medical negligence could also be of a criminal nature. The victim must file a case with the Consumer Forum/Commission of appropriate jurisdiction in order to initiate the claim. Fortunately, the Consumer Forums are pro-consumers, and hence, even in cases like medical negligence which are fairly difficult to prove, relief may be granted based on the merits of the case.
How can a Lawyer help you in case of Medical Negligence?
A lawyer experienced in the field of law relating to medical negligence is essential to further your interests in the quest for justice. A lawyer can best advise you on the merits of your case and the best plan of action to adopt moving forward.
A medical negligence lawyer will not only help you gain a proper understanding of your rights and remedies available in law but also manage the documentation required in this regard to best put forward your case. A lawyer will prepare your matter, based on the facts and circumstances of your particular case and will also represent and argue on your behalf. He/She will be able to tell you if you should go for a civil remedy or file a criminal case, or both.
A lawyer can also guide you and defend you, in case you are a doctor and a case of medical negligence has been filed against you. Thus, the first step that you should take is to consult a lawyer and get legal advice so that you can be guided upon the path to justice. You can also use LawRato's Ask a Free Question service to get free advice on your legal issue from expert lawyers.
These guides are not legal advice, nor a substitute for a lawyer
These articles are provided freely as general guides. While we do our best
to make sure these guides are helpful, we do not give any guarantee that
they are accurate or appropriate to your situation, or take any
responsibility for any loss their use might cause you. Do not rely on
information provided here without seeking experienced legal advice first. If
in doubt, please always consult a lawyer.
The internet is not a lawyer and neither are you.
Talk
to a real lawyer about your legal issue.
Comments by Users
No Comments! Be the first one to comment.
Related Articles
- How to claim compensation in medical negligence cases
- Doctor's liability in medical negligence cases
- All you need to know about Surrogacy Law in India
- how to file a case of medical negligence which happened 5 yrs back?
- Can i file a case against a doctor for Clinical negligence?
- Is selling research chemicals to customers online legal in India?
- Law on Medical Negligence in India: How and when to file a case
- Medical Negligence in India; Laws and Procedures
Medical Negligence Law Articles
User Reviews
4.7 - 19 reviews
Very informative and a good read as well.
Understood the subject with clarity.
great content. Thanks.
Very nice article. English is very simple. Thank you for the information.
very helpful and detailed
Tells all the legalities about the subject. Good work.
Very good article
Written in a very simple language.
its very helpful on the subject
good legal subject
good work
thanks for the advice
thanks for the information
informative
The article is written ver well. Learned a lot about my case through this.
thanks for the information
nicely explained. Thanks fro the information
Very helpful for my legal case.
thanks for the legal advice
VIEW ALL