LawRato

How to prove that a signature on a document is forged


15-Mar-2023 (In Criminal Law)
Have three documents, two with signatures of same person, which are genuine and match. Third document alleged forged signature of person who signed on document one and two mentioned earlier. Prima facie also this signature on doc 3 looks quite different from that on doc 1 and 2. However due to reasons unknown the person who has signed on doc 1 and 2 has declared that the signature on doc 3 is also made by him. My query, is it possible to prove from a handwriting expert which will be accepted in court of law that the signature on doc 3 is not made by the person who made the signature on doc 1 and 2.
Answers (5)

Answer #1
500 votes

In India, if a signature on a document is suspected to be forged, the party alleging the forgery can file an FIR with the police or a complaint with the court under Section 465, Indian Penal Code, 1860 which punishes the offence of forgery with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both. The following are the steps to prove that a signature on a document is forged:

  1. File a complaint: The first step is to file a complaint with the police, providing them with the necessary evidence, such as the original document, the alleged forged document, and any other relevant evidence. The police will initiate an investigation and may also seek the help of handwriting experts to determine whether the signature is forged or not.

  2. Expert Opinion: If the case goes to court, the party alleging forgery can present the opinion of a handwriting expert who can examine the signature and testify in court about whether the signature is genuine or forged. The court may also appoint its own handwriting expert for an independent opinion.

  3. Comparison of Signatures: Another way to prove forgery is by comparing the signature on the disputed document with other documents that are known to have been signed by the same person. If the signature on the disputed document does not match the signatures on the other documents, it can be considered as evidence of forgery.

  4. Cross-examination of Witnesses: The court may also cross-examine witnesses who have knowledge of the signature, such as witnesses who were present when the document was signed, to determine the authenticity of the signature.

Once it has been established that the signature on the document is forged, the court may take appropriate action, such as declaring the document null and void, and initiating legal action against the person responsible for the forgery.


People also ask

How do you prove a forgery case?

The document in dispute or the electronic recording is a fake document. The document has been forged by the accused. The document was forged to cheat the accused.

How is forgery detected?

The key to detecting a forgery is that each object contains evidence about the time and place of its creation. The two approaches of stylistic analysis and technical analysis are complementary, and they are best used in conjunction.

How do you fight a forgery case?

The prosecution must prove that you forged a document with the intent to deceive someone or commit fraud. One of the best ways to defend against forgery charges and prove that fraud was not the intent is by challenging the prosecutions evidence.

  
Answer #2
762 votes
OPINION OF A HAND WRITING EXPERT IS A SECONDARY EVIDENCE UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 45 OF THE INDIAN EVIDENCE ACT. THE COURT MAY OR MAY NOT RELY ON THE OPINION OF HAND WRITING EXPERT AS IT IS NOT A CONCLUSIVE PROOF OF EVIDENCE. YOU MAY USE THE EXPERT OPINION FOR CROSS- EXAMINATION OF WITNESS WHO SIGNED THE THIRD DOCUMENT DEMOLISH THE FACT THAT HE HAD SIGNED THE THIRD DOCUMENT
Answer #3
830 votes
The main thing here is wether sign made is against will of the appropriate candidates if appropriate candidate refuses to accept the sign then There are many private reputated organization working in the same field you can call it as hand writing experts there reports can also be helpful for you in proving yourself.

Answer #4
770 votes
Expert Opinion is a solid piece of evidence in Court of Law.
As far as your case is concerned, I am bit confused as to which side exactly you want to be.?
If the person has himself disclosed that signature on Doc-3 is made by him in his recorded testimony then this will be a matter of relevancy during trial and will go against the accused person.
However, report of an expert opinion regarding signature will be a strong evidence in favour of accused if it happens to be a positive one.
Answer #5
428 votes
Proving that a signature on a document is forged in court involves a meticulous process. Here are the steps and considerations:
  1. Obtain Expert Opinion: The first step is to consult a handwriting expert. They can analyze the signature in question and provide a professional opinion on whether it is forged. Their expertise is crucial in establishing the forgery.
  2. Collect Exemplars: To support your case, you should gather genuine samples of the person's signature (exemplars). These should ideally be from around the same time as the disputed signature. The court will use these exemplars for comparison.
  3. File a Police Complaint: Report the suspected forgery to the police and file a complaint. They may conduct their investigation and may involve a forensic expert if necessary.
  4. Document Examination Report: The forensic expert may issue a Document Examination Report detailing their findings regarding the signature's authenticity or forgery.
  5. Legal Representation: Consult with an attorney experienced in forgery cases. They will guide you through the legal process, help you gather evidence, and represent your case in court.
  6. Burden of Proof: In legal proceedings, the burden of proof rests on the party making the forgery claim. You will need to establish a strong case, primarily through the expert's testimony and evidence.
  7. Cross-Examination: During the trial, the opposing party may cross-examine the handwriting expert to challenge their opinion. Your attorney should be prepared for this.
  8. Court Proceedings: The court will evaluate the evidence presented, including the expert's opinion, exemplars, and any other relevant documents. They will make a judgment based on the preponderance of evidence.
  9. Penalties: If the court determines that forgery has occurred, the penalties for signature forgery in India can include imprisonment and fines. The severity of the punishment depends on the specific circumstances of the case.
Helpful? LawRato LawRato

Disclaimer: The above query and its response is NOT a legal opinion in any way whatsoever as this is based on the information shared by the person posting the query at lawrato.com and has been responded by one of the Divorce Lawyers at lawrato.com to address the specific facts and details.

Report abuse?

Comments by Users

ADVOCATE MUKESH AGARWAL
If signature are suspected forged FIR must be filed or complaint in court u/s 465 of IPC, court appoint handwriting expert. If signature on document does not match the documents are null and void,

"lawrato.com has handpicked some of the best Legal Experts in the country to help you get practical Legal Advice & help."